Because the Fight! Development blog post, and additionally this publisher, agree totally that Korean socialism try supremely popular, the last paragraph expresses new main dispute with the bit:
For the and of alone, Whitehouse’s hit-part toward Korean socialism is not worth the bandwidth it needs upwards as it doesn’t make major arguments resistant to the Fight back!
“How come Koreans mourn the fresh death of Kim Jong-Il? S. control, their commitment to the newest reunification and the genuine achievements out-of socialism. In the face of people who salary conflict for exploitation and you will oppression, Kim’s choices portrayed the fresh goals out of Korean experts, peasants, girls and children – the fresh new joined Korean country – to possess freedom. Even though Kim Jong Il has gone by aside, the newest Korean individuals will always february forward increasing the flag out-of federal reunification, self-determination and revolution.” (۱)
Away from just ‘certifying this new popular credentials’ of your DPRK, the fresh new mass outpouring away from despair by Korean people have shown this new extensive knowledge of the profits from Korean socialism therefore the tireless strive for federal reunification.
By way of example, Whitehouse periods the fight Back! Development blog post from the saying that the fresh new term, “”Korea stands good,” they are referring to the strength of the official. Simple fact is that same declare that has actually two hundred,one hundred thousand governmental prisoners, considering Amnesty In the world. Simple fact is that exact same state that shot deceased three North Korean residents have been seeking to get across this new edging toward Asia inside the late December.” (۴)
Central on the ISO’s anti-communism are huge reliance upon bourgeois provide that have demonstrated by themselves unable to endure the simplest materialist scrutiny
A far more principled study of the latest Korean jail system throughout the north – named good ‘gulag’ because of the bourgeoisie additionally the ISO equivalent – ironically is inspired by bourgeois historian Bruce Cumings. In his 2004 guide, North Korea: A different country, the guy cards that every claims concerning the Korean penal program are grossly overstated. As an example, he notes you to definitely “Preferred bad guys who to go lesser felonies and you may small fry [sic] which have an incorrect master on the invest your family county exactly who commit low-height political offenses come-off to help you labor camps or mines for work and you can differing lengths regarding incarceration,” the reason for which is to “reeducate them.” (۳) Which reflects good materialist knowledge of new sources from offense, occurring for the higher region off a person’s issue criteria and wrong facts, that may changes due to switching somebody’s criteria. It is vital to remember that a lot of criminals inside the fresh new Korean penal program get into this category and thus the fresh new point should be to rehabilitate and you can reeducate, instead of the punitive tries of Western penal program.
Cumings cards the brand new contrast ranging from Popular Korea’s violent fairness program and you can regarding the us, particularly in regards to a great prisoner’s connection with and support of their loved ones. He writes:
“The fresh new Aquariums from Pyongyang is an intriguing and plausible tale, precisely as it does not, in general, produce brand new ghastly tale away from totalitarian repression that its modern editors in France intended that it is; rather, they means that a good ily are survivable and not necessarily an enthusiastic challenge to 
help you entering the top-notch standing of quarters during the Pyongyang and you can entrances to school. At the same time we have a long-condition, never-end gulag laden with black colored people within prisons, incarcerating up from 25 % of all the black colored children.” (۳)
That time in new Korean penal program does not bring about social castigation adore it do when you look at the capitalist places reflects a good stark point out-of examine having capitalist penal solutions. Having fun with an individual’s members of the family since an assistance network, the official encourages political reeducation and you may opens opportunities getting rehabilitated prisoners so you’re able to re-enter into Korean area given that full owners.
Reports bit that it was designed to respond. Although not, they remains very important to Marxist-Leninists in order to confront the latest ISO’s book and you can distressing mixture of left-anticommunism when it pops up and you will defend the earnings of Korean some body.